Book review - Spineless

 

Title: Spineless

Author: Samantha San Miguel

Genre: historical fiction/fantasy

Similar books: Otter Lagoon by Nancy Deas

                     Lemons by Melissa Savage

Rating:

 

interesting elements

Summary (provided by publisher): When his asthma lands him at a health resort in the wilds of Gilded Age South Florida, twelve-year-old Algie Emsworth is over the moon. The scientific treasure trove of unexplored swamps may launch his dream career as a naturalist. But even Algie is startled when he happens upon a brand-new species and her brood in the karst springs surrounding the resort. Algie quickly realizes he must keep his discovery a secret: a famous collector of exotic animals is also staying at the hotel, and the new species is threatened by his very presence. An apparent curse has also descended upon the hotel, bringing with it a deadly red tide. But when the pool starts filling with ink and guests start getting mysterious, sucker-shaped wounds, Algie must pluck up his courage to find the truth about the goings-on at the Grand Hotel—and save the new species from destruction.

My opinion: The strongest part of this book is it's focus on science and responsible exploration. Algie and his new friends want to make important discoveries. It's a vital part of their plans to become famous naturalists. At the same time they want to be sure of what they have found. Additionally, they decide to prioritize the safety of their discovery over their own desires. It's a book that values altruism and shames personal gain. The messaging is a bit blunt and heavy handed, the characters a bit thin in their exploration, especially the 'villain' types. Additionally there is more conflict than action, so it's not the most thrilling read. Still, a decent choice for kids who enjoy more of an historical setting.

Advanced Reader Copy provided by NetGalley