Book review - A Bit of Earth

 

Title: A Bit of Earth

Author: Karuna Riazi

Genre: magical realism/retelling

Similar books: The Tigers in the Tower by Julia Golding

                      Listening for Lions by Gloria Whelan

Rating:

 

most interesting in comparison

Summary (provided by publisher): Growing up in Pakistan, Maria Latif has been bounced between reluctant relatives for as long as she can remember—first because of her parents’ constant travel, and then because of their deaths. Maria has always been a difficult child, and it never takes long for her guardians to tire of her. So when old friends of her parents offer to “give her a better life” in the United States, Maria is shipped to a host family across the world.
When Maria arrives on Long Island, things are not quite what she was expecting. Mr. Clayborne has left on an extended business trip, Mrs. Clayborne seems emotionally fraught, and inexplicable things keep happening in the Claybornes’ sprawling house. And then Maria finds a locked gate to an off-limits garden. Since she’s never been good at following rules, Maria decides to investigate and discovers something she never thought she’d find: a place where she feels at home.

My opinion: I wasn't sure that a modern retelling of The Secret Garden would really work. So many of the plot elements of the original story aren't really relevant any more. But the bones of the story are here - a disagreeable child sent to live with people who don't really know what to do with her; a boy who doesn't want her around; the restorative power of working in the earth. There are significant differences, of course, but I think those changes work in this book's favor. They make Maria's story a bit more universal. We all have moments where we don't feel like we belong in the place where we've found ourselves. There are some plot elements that are underdeveloped, especially the role of the two Mrs Claybornes but overall I think it's an interesting read, especially for a kid who has recently read the classic original.

More information: A Bit of Earth releases March 14.

Advanced Reader Copy provided by NetGalley