Book review - Maizy Chen's Last Chance

 

Title: Maizy Chen's Last Chance

Author: Lisa Yee

Genre: realistic fiction

Similar books: Hike to Home by Jess Rinker

                     Partly Cloudy by Tanita S Davis

Rating:

 

interesting without becoming intense

Summary (provided by publisher): Welcome to the Golden Palace!
Maizy has never been to Last Chance, Minnesota . . . until now. Her mom’s plan is just to stay for a couple weeks, until her grandfather gets better. But plans change, and as Maizy spends more time in Last Chance and at the Golden Palace—the restaurant that’s been in her family for generations—she makes some discoveries.For instance:
    You can tell a LOT about someone by the way they order food.
    People can surprise you. Sometimes in good ways, sometimes in disappointing ways.
    And the Golden Palace has secrets...
But the more Maizy discovers, the more questions she has. Like, why are her mom and her grandmother always fighting? Who are the people in the photographs on the office wall? And when she discovers that a beloved family treasure has gone missing—and someone has left a racist note—Maizy decides it’s time to find the answers.

My opinion: Yee has created a solid balance between Maizy's modern experience and the stories about her family's connection to Minnesota. There are thematic parallels between the two that encourage young readers to reflect and compare. It's not terribly deep, perhaps, but hits about right for a fourth or fifth grader. More importantly, the characters are realistic and well developed. We care about these characters and even secondary and tertiary characters have multiple aspects. A solid read for most any middle grade reader.

Advanced Reader Copy provided by NetGalley

Listen with me

 

The Chaperone by M Hendrix

Going into this book I saw it as having potential to revitalize the tired teen dystopian fiction market. That was, perhaps, too much pressure to put on a single book. It didn't blow me away. Honestly, I think it over-simplifies it's conflict. A truly compelling dystopian novel relies on one of two ideas: either it's impossible to escape or the alternative is too dangerous. That's where this book fails. New America is too obviously "bad" as it strips girls of all agency. When Stella learns about the truth about Old America, it is too obviously "good". She sees only the benefits. There is no true dilemma and not enough explanation as to how New America happened or why people stayed. While the concept is strong there isn't enough nuance to the plot. I applaud Hendrix for recognizing how our current political climate could go horribly awry but I don't fully love this book.

Advanced Reader Copy provided by NetGalley

Book review - Almost There and Almost Not

 

Title: Almost There and Almost Not

Author: Linda Urban

Genre: magical realism

Similar books: The Elephant's Girl by Celesta Rimington

                      Spirit's Key by Edith Cohn

Rating:

 

well balanced

Summary (provided by publisher): California Poppy has been dropped off, yet again, with an unsuspecting relative. This time it’s her eccentric Great-Aunt Monica, a woman she’s never even met. Aunt Monica has no idea what to do with an eleven-year-old, so she puts California to work researching their ancestor, the once-famous etiquette expert Eleanor Fontaine.
California soon discovers that Great-Great-Great Aunt Eleanor is...not exactly alive and well, but a ghost—and a super sensitive one at that. The grand dame bursts into clouds of dust whenever she loses her composure, which happens quite often. Still, an unexpected four-legged friend and some old-fashioned letter writing make this decidedly strange situation one that California can handle.
Just as California’s starting to feel like she’s found a place for herself, life turns upside-down yet again. Thankfully, this time she has some friends almost by her side...

My opinion: Urban has found the perfect balance of elements to make this a nearly gentle, sensitive read. With a largely abandoned child character encountering ghosts and living with a grief-stricken relative it could easily become maudlin and over-wrought. Instead we meet a likeable, far from perfect protagonist learning to handle her overwhelming emotions and coming to terms with the ways her father has failed her. Through her encounters with the ghost she learns about the complexities of all people and her lessons in calligraphy and etiquette help her to express herself more clearly. It may not be a thrilling book but it is a thoughtful one and may be good for discussion with young readers.

Advanced Reader Copy provided by NetGalley

Book review - Back to the Bright Before

 

Title: Back to the Bright Before

Author: Katherin Nolte

Genre: magical realism

Similar books: Looking for True by Tricia Springstubb

                      The Midnight Children by Dan Gemeinhart

Rating:

 

I'm not fully sure about this one

Summary (provided by publisher): When eleven-year-old Pet Martin’s dad falls from a ladder on their family farm, it isn’t just his body that crashes to the ground. So does every hope her family had for the future. Money is scarce, and Pet’s mom is bone-tired from waiting tables at the local diner, and even with the extra hours, it’s not enough for a third surgery for Pet’s dad. Her five-year-old brother, Simon, now refuses to say anything except the word “cheese.” Worst of all? The ladder accident was Pet’s fault.
She’s determined to fix things—but how? Good old-fashioned grit…and maybe a little bit of magic.
When a neighbor recites a poem about an ancient coin hidden somewhere on the grounds of the local abbey, Pet forms a plan. With her brother, a borrowed chicken, and a stolen pony, Pet runs away from home. If she can find the coin, Daddy can have his surgery, Momma can stop her constant working, and Simon might speak again. But Pet isn't the only one who wants the coin…which means searching for it is more dangerous than she ever imagined.

My opinion: There are solid elements at play here. It's a quest for a treasure - a special coin that can solve all of this family's problems. We have a lurking villain and a charming, if somewhat strange, assortment of details. Nuns, taffy, a chicken, a treasure, and chainsaw carving are not things we expect to see together but Nolte makes them work. It's the quest itself that gives me some pause. Because when Pet and Simon set out on their quest they seem to leave the natural world behind. They encounter a series of increasingly odd beings that tell them stories about their parents, shedding light on their past and the influences on their current situation. The journey feels far more symbolic than literal, even in the world of the book, and that creates an emotional distance that may make it difficult for young readers to engage.

Advanced Reader Copy provided by NetGalley

Pick 6: history

 Sometimes history can be a struggle to understand. It tends to be presented as a series of facts, disconnected from everything else. We may not recognize why it matters. And that's why I like historical fiction. A good book set in the past helps to personalize the past, to make it real and remind us that these dry events we learn in class happened to regular people. Here are six historical fiction novels published in the past six months.

Six new historical novels

1. For Lamb by Lesa Cline-Ransome
2. The Lost Year by Katherine Marsh
3. Wild Bird by Diane Zahler
4. Bea and the New Deal Horse by L M Ellis
5. A Sky Full of Song by Susan Lynn Meyer
6. When Clouds Touch Us by Thanha Lai
   

Non-fiction book review - Stamped from the Beginning

 

Stamped from the Beginning by Ibram X Kendi; adapted by Joel Christian Gill

Unraveling racism and it's place in our history and culture is a huge task. Expecint anyone to grasp all of the nuance seems nearly impossible. This book will help. By explaining concepts visually as much as with text we have an easier time digesting the concepts. Of course, the graphic novel format is limited in some aspects and means that a lot of nuance will be left out. That is to say, this is by no means a full exploration of the ideas and history. Instead, think of this book as a primer. It's an introduction that will get the reader thinking critically about racism and culture so they can go into a traditional text with some understanding.

Advanced Reader Copy provided by NetGalley

Book review - Falling Out of TIme

 

Title: Falling Out of Time

Author: Margaret Peterson Haddix

Genre: dystopia

Similar books: The Town With No Mirrors by Christina Collins

                      The List by Patricia Fforde

Rating:

 

a bit of a let down

Summary (provided by publisher): Twelve-year-old Zola thinks she has the perfect life. She thinks everyone does, now that it’s 2193, and humanity has solved all its problems. Insta-Closets deliver new clothes every morning, Insta-Ovens deliver gourmet meals on demand, and virtual reality goggles let her have any adventure she wants, with friends from all over the world.
Then one day Zola finds a handwritten note in her Insta-Closet:
If you want to see things as they really are, come find me.
What if Zola’s wrong about everything—even the year? As she struggles to figure out who wrote the note, she discovers a printed book in her Insta-Closet called The Jessie Keyser Story: How One Girl Escaped from Clifton Village. Zola wonders: Who is Jessie Keyser, and why does she look like her . . . and what else do they have in common?

My opinion: I feel like I should preface this by saying that I read Running Out of Time when it was still fairly new and I was a young teen. I loved the book and it made Haddix one of my "must read" authors for several years. But that's been a couple of decades and I haven't read it since. So maybe this book is suffering for me in comparison with an idealized memory. That being said, most of my criticisms remain. My biggest complaint is that this book didn't feel necessary. I do understand the desire to revisit the world of a book, especially taking into account how attitudes have shifted in the intervening years. You want to explore how new issues and ideas would influence the culture of the book. The problem for me is that this book basically follows the same plot as the first one. While the details are different, the thrust of the plot remains essentially the same. Additionally, the villain lacks focus and proper motivation. There are seeds for a more complex exploration of class structure, grief, and responsibility but they don't get much beyond introduction.

Advanced Reader Copy provided by NetGalley